Search
luggagerateluggagerate
Debating between saving money or investing in premium performance? The Travelers Club Richmond is one of the most affordable softside carry-ons, while the Travelpro Maxlite Air brings high-end construction and polished handling. In this breakdown, we explore how they compare across materials, handling, organization, and overall value.
Softside Carry-On
Hardside Carry-On
Travelpro’s polycarbonate build is more durable and weather-resistant than Richmond’s polyester.
Maxlite Air has better organization with dividers and tie-downs.
Travelpro glides more smoothly and handles rough surfaces better.
Richmond wins on price, but Travelpro offers higher-end materials and support.
"Travelers praise the Richmond’s lightweight design and low cost but report occasional zipper issues and fabric wear after a few trips."
"Maxlite Air earns strong marks for its glide, durability, and upscale appearance. Users say it feels like a premium carry-on at a mid-range price."
The Richmond’s polyester shell is great for flexibility and budget-friendly travelers but lacks long-term durability. It’s more prone to rips and shows wear faster. Travelpro’s Maxlite Air uses 100% polycarbonate, offering better protection from impacts and scratches. Its water-resistant design also helps keep your contents dry in rough weather—something softside bags struggle with. Travelpro wins this category on all fronts.
The Richmond’s interior is simple and spacious, best suited for travelers who don’t need a lot of compartmentalization. It expands to give extra space but doesn’t have many organizing features. The Maxlite Air offers a clamshell design with a zippered divider and cross straps. While the total volume might be similar, the Maxlite Air makes better use of space for keeping your things tidy.
Richmond’s spinner wheels are serviceable but not built for frequent rolling over rough surfaces. The Maxlite Air’s 8-wheel system glides smoothly in all directions and the handle feels sturdier and more refined. At 6.3 lbs, it’s surprisingly light for a hardshell, nearly matching the Richmond in weight while outperforming in control and comfort.
The Richmond looks functional and leans more traditional, available in common colors like black and navy. The Maxlite Air has a sleek, modern aesthetic with subtle ridges and a glossy finish. Travelpro also offers more contemporary color options. If you want a suitcase that looks like it belongs in business class, go with the Maxlite.
Travelers Club doesn’t have the strongest track record for support, and warranty claims can be hit or miss. Travelpro is known for its customer service and offers a limited lifetime warranty that covers airline damage. If support and long-term use are key, the Maxlite Air is the safer bet.
Surprisingly, the Maxlite Air is slightly lighter at 6.3 lbs compared to Richmond’s 6.6 lbs.
No, neither model has a built-in USB port.
If you want a basic, low-cost bag for occasional travel, Richmond is perfectly serviceable. But if you value quality, handling, and long-term durability, the Travelpro Maxlite Air is well worth the investment.
Budget-conscious travelers or infrequent flyers.
Frequent travelers who want reliable performance without going overboard on price.
Have you traveled with either of these models? Drop your thoughts and let other travelers know how they perform in the real world.