Search
luggagerateluggagerate
Choosing between a softside and a hardside carry-on often comes down to your travel habits. The Travelers Club Richmond offers budget-friendly flexibility, while the U.S. Traveler Boren adds modern materials and features like a USB port and rigid protection. In this side-by-side breakdown, we compare these two popular models to help you find the right fit for your travel needs.
Softside Carry-On
Hardside Carry-On
Boren’s polycarbonate build is tougher and more protective than Richmond’s softside fabric.
Richmond offers more flexible packing, while Boren delivers better structure and organization.
Boren’s wheels and aluminum handle provide smoother handling.
Richmond is extremely affordable, but Boren adds better materials and tech.
"Travelers like Richmond’s lightweight feel and how much it can hold, though a few mention durability issues after multiple trips."
"Boren gets praise for its smooth ride and tech-friendly USB port. Many users say it performs above its price point."
The Richmond is a lightweight softside made of polyester—ideal for squeezing into overhead bins and allowing a bit of extra give when packing. However, it’s more prone to wear and tear, and won’t protect fragile items as well. The U.S. Traveler Boren, by contrast, uses a tough polycarbonate shell that’s better at handling impacts. Its aluminum handle adds to the premium build feel. If you're looking for durability, the Boren clearly has the edge.
With its soft construction, the Richmond offers a slightly roomier feel and is easier to overpack. Its compartments are basic but functional, with enough room for a weekend trip. The Boren, while more structured, features a more refined interior, with compression straps and a divider for better organization. If neat packing is your priority, the Boren offers a tidier layout.
Both models have spinner wheels, but U.S. Traveler’s Boren rolls smoother, thanks to a better wheelbase and a high-grade telescopic aluminum handle. The Richmond is lightweight and easy to lift but may feel flimsier and less stable on uneven terrain. The Boren feels more premium when navigating airports or crowded terminals.
The Richmond has a classic softside appearance, available in conservative colorways that suit casual or occasional travelers. The Boren leans modern with a glossy finish and cleaner lines, plus the high-tech vibe is accentuated by the integrated USB port. If you care about making a sleek impression, the Boren stands out more visually.
Travelers Club provides basic warranty coverage, though support can be hit or miss depending on the seller. U.S. Traveler offers a slightly more robust support network and has better feedback from long-term customers when it comes to resolving warranty issues.
The U.S. Traveler Boren, thanks to its polycarbonate shell and tighter structure.
Possibly, depending on the airline. Its softside build allows more flexibility than a hardshell.
If your priority is affordability and you don’t mind a soft shell, the Richmond is a lightweight and budget-friendly choice. But for travelers wanting a more modern, protective, and durable carry-on with bonus features like a USB port, the Boren is worth the slightly higher price.
Light packers and casual travelers looking for a low-cost carry-on.
Tech-savvy or frequent travelers who want durable build and modern features.
Tried either of these suitcases? Share your experience and help fellow travelers choose their next perfect carry-on!