Two softside carry-ons go head-to-head: the Travelpro Maxlite 5 and SwissGear Sion Softside. They’re both lightweight and designed for efficient packing, but cater to slightly different types of travelers. Let’s dive into which one gives you more bang for your buck—and better performance on the road.

Softside Carry-On

Softside Carry-On
Travelpro’s finish and materials are more polished and lightweight.
Maxlite 5 offers better organization; SwissGear has useful exterior pockets.
Maxlite 5’s spinner wheels are smoother and it’s significantly lighter.
SwissGear is budget-friendly; Travelpro gives more longevity for your dollar.
"Maxlite 5 fans highlight how light and easy it is to handle. Many frequent travelers stick with it for that reason alone."
"Sion users enjoy the multiple pockets and rugged feel but sometimes note the extra weight and wobble when full."
The Travelpro Maxlite 5 is constructed from a lightweight polyester with a water-resistant coating, giving it an edge in wet weather and long-term durability. It’s well-stitched, with a premium feel despite its mid-range price tag. On the other hand, the SwissGear Sion Softside also uses tough polyester, but the material is noticeably heavier and lacks the same refined finish. That said, SwissGear adds reinforced corner guards and sturdy zippers that hold up decently over time. Travelpro’s build is more refined overall, but SwissGear’s build is respectable for the price.
Travelpro’s Maxlite 5 interior includes a full-length lid pocket, cross straps, and a wet pocket, giving it thoughtful organization without wasting space. It also expands slightly, which helps if you’re the kind to overpack. SwissGear’s Sion keeps things simpler with elastic tie-down straps and a zippered mesh compartment, but offers quick-access exterior pockets that many travelers love for stashing last-minute items. If you prefer detailed internal organization, the Maxlite 5 wins—but for simplicity and access, SwissGear delivers.
Both bags use spinner wheels, but the Maxlite 5’s are smoother and quieter, especially on rougher surfaces. It’s also noticeably lighter at just 5.4 lbs, compared to SwissGear’s 7 lbs, making a big difference when lifting into overhead compartments or rushing through terminals. SwissGear rolls fine on clean, flat surfaces but can wobble when fully loaded. For frequent flyers or older travelers, the Maxlite 5 offers better maneuverability.
Travelpro offers a limited lifetime warranty on the Maxlite 5, which includes a trusted customer service reputation and coverage against manufacturing defects. SwissGear typically provides a 5-year warranty, which is fair for the price but not as robust. For long-term peace of mind, Travelpro provides more confidence, especially if you're investing in a carry-on you'll use frequently.
Only the Travelpro Maxlite 5 includes an expandable compartment. The SwissGear Sion is fixed in capacity.
The Maxlite 5, thanks to its 5.4 lb weight, is easier to lift and carry around airports.
The Travelpro Maxlite 5 is a smart choice for frequent flyers looking for light weight, smooth mobility, and thoughtful design. The SwissGear Sion Softside is a reliable pick for casual or budget-conscious travelers who value utility and front-pocket access.
Light packers, older travelers, and frequent fliers.
Budget travelers and those who prefer quick access to front compartments.
Used either of these on a recent trip? Let us know which one rolled better for you in the comments!